|
| | [Kureiji Unit] MEP - Payphone | |
| | Author | Message |
---|
Liar Kureiji Unit
Posts : 42 Join date : 2016-04-30 Age : 27 Location : Romania
| Subject: [Kureiji Unit] MEP - Payphone Tue Feb 14, 2017 1:12 am | |
| Sorry for the long post. Here is a pigeon .
Last edited by Liar on Tue Feb 14, 2017 3:17 am; edited 3 times in total | |
| | | Axel Kureiji Unit
Posts : 16 Join date : 2016-06-08 Location : Void
| Subject: Re: [Kureiji Unit] MEP - Payphone Tue Feb 14, 2017 1:13 am | |
| IS THIS REAL ? AM I NOT DREAMING ? THE MEME ! THE LEGEND ! IT'S HERE BOYSSSSSSS ! | |
| | | Hakuryuu
Posts : 9 Join date : 2016-08-26 Age : 27
| Subject: Re: [Kureiji Unit] MEP - Payphone Tue Feb 14, 2017 12:59 pm | |
| okay well first of all congratz for finishing this mep xDD i thought it'll never be done hehe xp 2nd of all i expected it to be much better but i think that it's no difference from all the previous meps that u guys made to b extremely honest , since apparently the whole mep was a mess - Boring stuff:
Track 1 : the pacing overall was nice but the it could be better to use another anime instead of Elfen Lied , something like "Saint Seiya- The Lost Canvas" would fit pretty much better i daresay , but the part overall doesn't have that much amount of errors
Track 2 : i have a feeling that it was used on both SV & AE since there's a frame blending in the whole part , besides that i couldn't really like the way it was done ( the MEP was basically supposed to have anime scenes not animated pictures with more or less rough cam movements from time to time )
Track 3 : the scenes selection doesn't look that good @ all & even the cc makes the quality of the part overall looks fucked up & add to it the spammed slides & zooms which gives it more continuity errors
Track 4 : i liked the way it was done tbh , ray never disappointed me in action editing overall xD counting on the lips sync in the beginning of the part with some cam movements to give a better impact from time to time was a good idea to me , nothing much to say about it , it might have some problems when it comes to the flames scenes usage ( it could be better if it was not used in huge numbers @ the beginning of the part & replace them by flame particular overlays ) + some spammed lights here & there , although the part looks good enough comparing to the rest
Track 5 : okay , the usage of Erased was totally outta the place to start with , & furthermore the camera movements spam gives it more continuity errors + the random effects usage , if u want my advice , a good vid must not necessary contain a shitload of transitions & effects & ugly cc usage which can't make the viewer focus on a single scene , a good edit could have no special effects most of the time but have a great timing / great scenes selection & a great pacing , it'd be better to take some risks by using some effects here & there but not by spamming there like a maniac
Track 6 : same thing as for the previous part & the same problems goes on until Track 9 ( kekkai sensen )
Track 9 : the part apparently contain a good mood presentation comparing to the previous part of urs as well as a more or less good presentation for the characters presentation , it have potential but it could be better ( @ the very least i can keep focus on some scenes )
Track 10 : the 3D text wasn't necessary @ all , + the kirito negative effect & some transitions here & there that they could be simply replaced by some film burn overlay or blur transitions , the fire overlays usage was spammed as well , even if it meant to be a material usage but it was totally bad , still there's some good passages between some scenes in the second half @ 2:04 to be more precise , it's where mistakes get lesser than in the whole mep i think
Track 11 : i wished if the beginning of the berserk part was better than that ( material usage to fill up the space ) but the rest was pretty nice ( starting the scenes selection after the typo usage ) , nothing much to say again , nice job
Track 12 : perfectly done !! , i daresay that it's the best part in the mep literally , nothing wrong with it , just maybe it could be better if it had some blur @ the beginning of every scene maybe ?? or else it's the best part indeed , keep it up !!
Track 13 : there's some spammed rotations @ the beginning of the part but it doesn't bother that much , there's some sort of a good representation of the characters overall , good scenes selection most of the time , nothing much to say , not bad @ all but it could be better
Track 14 : nice part , maybe some transitions was way too smooth here & there so they doesn't fit properly but still good , keep it up !!
Track 15 : good scenes selection overall , the text could be simply replaced by a scene or a mask
overall the whole mep was a mess , random anime usage with no concept & bad organisation i daresay , next time u better try to make @ least something good in commun between all the parts
Last edited by Liar on Tue Feb 14, 2017 2:17 pm; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : 2 much nonsense) | |
| | | Liar Kureiji Unit
Posts : 42 Join date : 2016-04-30 Age : 27 Location : Romania
| Subject: Re: [Kureiji Unit] MEP - Payphone Tue Feb 14, 2017 2:16 pm | |
| - Hakuryuu wrote:
- okay well first of all congratz for finishing this mep xDD i thought it'll never be done hehe xp
2nd of all i expected it to be much better but i think that it's no difference from all the previous meps that u guys made to b extremely honest , since apparently the whole mep was a mess ... overall the whole mep was a mess , random anime usage with no concept & bad organisation i daresay , next time u better try to make @ least something good in commun between all the parts It took some time to be done indeed. There's a thing I don't understand from your 'little' post. Why you typed so much things? Believe me or not, we don't really care about your big opinion... I think that i'm the single one that read the whole thing and it got so annoying when i got at part 4. I do understand why you'd hate us/me and the reason why you posted that whole thing, but bruh... this is not even a contest, why the bother to type that much? A simple post would've been so much better and EASIER. Overall the whole post was a mess, random words usage with no concept behind it & bad organisation I daresay, next time u better try to make @ least a shorter good post in the forum between all the meps Have a butiful valentineh day! ^_^ | |
| | | Hakuryuu
Posts : 9 Join date : 2016-08-26 Age : 27
| Subject: Re: [Kureiji Unit] MEP - Payphone Tue Feb 14, 2017 2:22 pm | |
| - Quote:
- Liar wrote:
- Hakuryuu wrote:
- okay well first of all congratz for finishing this mep xDD i thought it'll never be done hehe xp
2nd of all i expected it to be much better but i think that it's no difference from all the previous meps that u guys made to b extremely honest , since apparently the whole mep was a mess ... overall the whole mep was a mess , random anime usage with no concept & bad organisation i daresay , next time u better try to make @ least something good in commun between all the parts It took some time to be done indeed. There's a thing I don't understand from your 'little' post. Why you typed so much things? Believe me or not, we don't really care about your big opinion... I think that i'm the single one that read the whole thing and it got so annoying when i got at part 4. I do understand why you'd hate us/me and the reason why you posted that whole thing, but bruh... this is not even a contest, why the bother to type that much? A simple post would've been so much better and EASIER.
Overall the whole post was a mess, random words usage with no concept behind it & bad organisation I daresay, next time u better try to make @ least a shorter good post in the forum between all the meps Have a butiful valentineh day! ^_^
why u're getting butthurted over no reason ?? forums r made for criticism , if u don't give a shit about it then just ignore , ez as that & who said that i hate anyone as well wtf ... | |
| | | Liar Kureiji Unit
Posts : 42 Join date : 2016-04-30 Age : 27 Location : Romania
| Subject: Re: [Kureiji Unit] MEP - Payphone Tue Feb 14, 2017 3:04 pm | |
| You really have some problems xD Who's getting butthurted lel | |
| | | Axel Kureiji Unit
Posts : 16 Join date : 2016-06-08 Location : Void
| Subject: Re: [Kureiji Unit] MEP - Payphone Tue Feb 14, 2017 4:57 pm | |
| - Hakuryuu wrote:
- okay well first of all congratz for finishing this mep xDD i thought it'll never be done hehe xp
2nd of all i expected it to be much better but i think that it's no difference from all the previous meps that u guys made to b extremely honest , since apparently the whole mep was a mess
- Boring stuff:
Track 1 : the pacing overall was nice but the it could be better to use another anime instead of Elfen Lied , something like "Saint Seiya- The Lost Canvas" would fit pretty much better i daresay , but the part overall doesn't have that much amount of errors
Track 2 : i have a feeling that it was used on both SV & AE since there's a frame blending in the whole part , besides that i couldn't really like the way it was done ( the MEP was basically supposed to have anime scenes not animated pictures with more or less rough cam movements from time to time )
Track 3 : the scenes selection doesn't look that good @ all & even the cc makes the quality of the part overall looks fucked up & add to it the spammed slides & zooms which gives it more continuity errors
Track 4 : i liked the way it was done tbh , ray never disappointed me in action editing overall xD counting on the lips sync in the beginning of the part with some cam movements to give a better impact from time to time was a good idea to me , nothing much to say about it , it might have some problems when it comes to the flames scenes usage ( it could be better if it was not used in huge numbers @ the beginning of the part & replace them by flame particular overlays ) + some spammed lights here & there , although the part looks good enough comparing to the rest
Track 5 : okay , the usage of Erased was totally outta the place to start with , & furthermore the camera movements spam gives it more continuity errors + the random effects usage , if u want my advice , a good vid must not necessary contain a shitload of transitions & effects & ugly cc usage which can't make the viewer focus on a single scene , a good edit could have no special effects most of the time but have a great timing / great scenes selection & a great pacing , it'd be better to take some risks by using some effects here & there but not by spamming there like a maniac
Track 6 : same thing as for the previous part & the same problems goes on until Track 9 ( kekkai sensen )
Track 9 : the part apparently contain a good mood presentation comparing to the previous part of urs as well as a more or less good presentation for the characters presentation , it have potential but it could be better ( @ the very least i can keep focus on some scenes )
Track 10 : the 3D text wasn't necessary @ all , + the kirito negative effect & some transitions here & there that they could be simply replaced by some film burn overlay or blur transitions , the fire overlays usage was spammed as well , even if it meant to be a material usage but it was totally bad , still there's some good passages between some scenes in the second half @ 2:04 to be more precise , it's where mistakes get lesser than in the whole mep i think
Track 11 : i wished if the beginning of the berserk part was better than that ( material usage to fill up the space ) but the rest was pretty nice ( starting the scenes selection after the typo usage ) , nothing much to say again , nice job
Track 12 : perfectly done !! , i daresay that it's the best part in the mep literally , nothing wrong with it , just maybe it could be better if it had some blur @ the beginning of every scene maybe ?? or else it's the best part indeed , keep it up !!
Track 13 : there's some spammed rotations @ the beginning of the part but it doesn't bother that much , there's some sort of a good representation of the characters overall , good scenes selection most of the time , nothing much to say , not bad @ all but it could be better
Track 14 : nice part , maybe some transitions was way too smooth here & there so they doesn't fit properly but still good , keep it up !!
Track 15 : good scenes selection overall , the text could be simply replaced by a scene or a mask
overall the whole mep was a mess , random anime usage with no concept & bad organisation i daresay , next time u better try to make @ least something good in commun between all the parts Thanks for taking your time to watch and review the mep Digi,it is a mess mostly because of the fact that there are too many styles in it,i still like it but it's one year old and some parts are new while other parts are old so that's why i think it's a bit of a mess,that and the fact that the song was kinda weird for us to edit on haha.Even if i disagree here and there i can see where you are coming from xD. | |
| | | Sponsored content
| Subject: Re: [Kureiji Unit] MEP - Payphone | |
| |
| | | | [Kureiji Unit] MEP - Payphone | |
|
Similar topics | |
|
| Permissions in this forum: | You cannot reply to topics in this forum
| |
| |
| |
|